BACK TO
WA GOOD FOOD GUIDE
WINE AWARDS
A celebration of the diversity of wine in Western Australia, the WA Good Food Guide Wine Awards presents a thrilling list of the state’s Top 25 wines for the year, along with award winners representing the apex of WA winemaking. Join us in raising a glass to all of them.
Welcome to the WA Good Food Guide Wine Awards for 2023, a celebration of all the breadth, diversity, talent and downright deliciousness that the state’s winemakers work so hard to deliver every single day. Overseen by our drinks director, Mike Bennie, the awards brings together a panel of local and national talent for a rigorous judging program that takes place over three days. Wines are blind-tasted, discussed, benchmarked, re-tasted and discussed again to land, ultimately, here, with our Top 25 of the year, and a list of exceptionally worthy award winners.
Each and every wine on this list represents the best of the best for the year, and is a benchmark for the state. Seek these out, put them on your wine lists, order a case from your local bottleshop, cellar some, drink some by the pool or at the table, but most of all, enjoy them.
THE YEAR IN WINE
The WA Good Food Guide Wine Awards is at the apex of the work I do each year.
The Awards represent best practice, forward thinking and diversity that speaks volumes, while the judging team is outstanding and represents a breadth of exceptional talent.
The results are contemporary, distinct and have a currency that speaks fluently of the range of wines and styles found in Western Australia, from blue-chip classic and regional heroes through to astutely produced experimental and emerging styles. It’s an honour to judge the wines, the calibre rising each year, with this year a high watermark.
Each year in judging we sit down to taste wines poured expertly by local wine talent from our numbered brown paper bags. Our quarry is to assess the hard work of WA winemakers and to, through a blind-tasting process, assemble a list that the public can value and dig into as a yardstick for this great state’s ability to produce myriad wine styles, with the wines on the final list resonating above all others.
Judges discuss, re-taste, and collate a top collection of 50-or-so wines, then whittle that group into a 25 that best represent all wines of WA. The 25 is ranked after a re-tasting and discussion and ipso we have our line up – a selection that should be proudly seen as an imprint of how interesting and good WA wine is with quality as the byword. It’s an extremely thorough and rigorous process that goes well beyond the classic wine-show system’s approach of aggregating scores and instantaneous decision making. We’re proud of this, and tout our best practice as a benchmark for wine judging in Australia.
Regional staples sit alongside the avant garde, surprises exist among the potentially expected, and the overall feel of the Top 25 is that it should resonate for everyone.
As for the results, well, they’re instantly appealing and impressive for their mix of new and old, traditional and contemporary. Regional staples sit alongside the avant garde, surprises exist among the potentially expected, and the overall feel of the Top 25 is that it should resonate for everyone, if not be a selection that feels kindred with all facets of wine consumption – from restaurants, to bars through to bottleshops, while leaning into early consumption at picnics, dinner parties, festivals or on the couch in front of the TV.
For the “best-ofs” it’s easy to look to Margaret River cabernet and chardonnay as readily adorned with superlatives, and we’ve been gifted with a best-of-the-best in 2023 through a tussle of palates and conversations. This is often the most scrutinised of decisions by those outside our blind tasting, but we feel we’ve put on a pedestal examples that deliver not only ephemeral notions of complexity and poise, but inherent drinkability and interest. Some surprises, and some that aren’t so surprising, are in the mix.
Great Southern has again shown us that riesling and shiraz are the benchmark varieties. Tightly wound, scintillating whites of riesling continue to impress, though it’s those with nuance of texture, savouriness and balanced acidity that come up trumps. Shiraz with perfume, silky texture, spice and bright red fruits charmed us, and we know the calibre is rising, if not showing the eastern states how a shift in culture with the variety is on hand.
Swan Valley, often maligned, continues to impress with chenin blanc and grenache, old regional varieties being done righteously, and in some cases with some modern interpretations that draw gaze back to this old region, and rightfully so. The younger generations of Australia’s second-oldest wine growing area breathe additional life into a fantastic place.
Around this, there’s a nod in the direction of WA’s potential with interesting blends, lesser-sung or lesser-known grape varieties, alternative styles and a derring-do with winemaking approaches. These wines bolster the expected with the unexpected, and in that round out an assembly of incredible producers that deliver contemporary drinking mores in the most emphatic sense.
Exciting, distinct, the Top 25 is a true representation of wine in WA in 2023, and one that we’re definitely proud of. Kudos to WA wine, and then some.
Mike Bennie,
Director of Drinks, WA Good Food Guide
THE JUDGES
Featuring Kate Goodman, Nick Ryan, Emma Farrelly, Erin Larkin and Nina Throsby, our judging panel is made up of some of the finest local and national voices in wine. Ranging from wine writers to sommeliers and winemakers and led by Drinks Director Mike Bennie, the goal is breadth of opinion, thorough discussion and ultimately consensus on what makes up the best of the best in WA wine, each and every year.
I was captivated by the diverse pool of entries, each a masterpiece in its own right, but what truly stood out was the remarkable theme of innovation and sustainable viticulture woven into the submissions.
Nina Throsby
The results are a celebration of some of the state’s most exciting and delicious wines, showcasing a range of styles and flavours that will have you coming back for more.
Kate Goodman
The thing that makes these awards so compelling is a judging process unlike any other. Over several days and hundreds of wines, we teach and we learn, we advocate and we listen, we shine a light on the wines we love and allow the light shone by others to illuminate a path we might not have otherwise taken
Nick Ryan
It’s always a pleasure to judge the excellent wines from our corner of Australia. WA continues to impress, with diverse, inspired wines that speak beautifully of place.
Emma Farrelly
The WAGFG process is shaped to find the wines that deliver the most joy and pleasure to the drinker. This is ultimately why we all buy wine, and it makes so much sense to judge them in this spirit. The final 25 are whittled down from a pool of approximately 400, down to 50, down to these. Every wine that is here has been enjoyed, discussed, and marvelled at, and has its own reason for inclusion. What a cool way to approach the finish line: instead of asking, ‘does it pass the threshold?’, we openly ask each other, ‘do we love it? ’The answer ultimately, has to be, yes. An emphatic yes: we love it, we’d buy it, we’d drink it. What an affirmation!
Erin Larkin
THE TOP 25
-
Battles Frankland River Shiraz
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
Poised, vibrant, persistent and downright beautiful.
An outstanding wine from every angle, this satin-textured, perfumed, poised and utterly delicious red delivers all the detail of red berries, spice, savoury earthiness and layers of fine, puckering tannin. All this, delivered in a seamless flow that’s poised, vibrant, persistent and downright beautiful. That it’s gulpable, as well as something to pause and reflect on, is a distinct asset. What a wine.
-
McHenry Hohnen Hazel’s Vineyard Chardonnay
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
Good length and depth of flavour, and although there’s intensity, there’s balance.
A nod to Jura here perhaps, with saline notes, nuts, faint fino sherry characters and green apple. To go with it, there’s good length and depth of flavour, and although there’s intensity, there’s balance. Throughout, you can sense a clear focus on chardonnay staying the hero, with a goal to maximise the intensity of flavour and support it with freshness and interest. A brilliant wine.
-
Fraser Gallop Estate Parterre Cabernet Sauvignon
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
A hedonistic red of elegance and refinement that delivers strong and worthy regional character.
Fresh and bright, tightly wound and succulent, this is a hedonistic red of elegance and refinement that delivers strong and worthy regional character. Displaying characters of red and blue fruits, sage and bay leaf notes along with woody spice, there’s an overriding feeling of freshness, supported by beautiful tension and a great extension of flavour. A wonderful expression.
-
La Violetta Das Sakrileg
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
A complex and complete wine that delivers way more than the usual.
An outstanding riesling here. So complete and so good, with savoury, succulent and bright lemon and ginger, notes of toast and yeast, a hint of almond and plenty more. Some saline and briny elements contribute to what is a very complex and complete wine that delivers way more than the usual.
-
Deep Woods Estate Reserve Chardonnay
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
There’s amplitude, yes, but there’s sexiness in equal measure to go with a serious feeling and great length.
A concentrated and richer style here, with lots of woody spices, nectarine, green mango, a touch of green herb and faint brioche characters. Spicy to taste, oak is a dominant factor but it feels like the fruit is up to task and the two work harmoniously together. There’s amplitude, yes, but there’s sexiness in equal measure to go with a serious feeling and great length. Great quality here.
-
Cherubino Nebbiolo
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
A distinct and distinguished wine delivering strong DNA of the variety with drinkability in tow.
A wow moment. Such a distinct and distinguished wine delivering strong DNA of the variety with drinkability in tow. It’s bright and fresh, but with mettle from good tannin, succulent texture and vibrant fruit. Savoury in style, with brightness shining through, there’s an appealing dusty, Italianate feel to it all. Good stuff here, and very well done.
-
Frankland Estate Franc
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
A wonderful expression with high drinkability.
Spice, herbs, blue fruits, tension and freshness meet purity. So shimmery and fresh, this wine shines on the palate. It’s beautiful and pretty in its way, with a fine tannin profile, great extension of flavour, and a riff on all green herbs and spice. A wonderful expression with high drinkability.
-
Swinney Mourvèdre
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
A chewy, chunkier style, but one that delivers a near dictionary-definition of the variety.
There’s dark berries, floral violet lift, a touch of meatiness, bay leaf, black pepper and some saline mineral notes, followed by a haze of spicy tannin. Great to see the savouriness writ large. Compelling.
-
Vino Volta Post Modern Seriousism Grenache
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
Great drinking – easy drinking – is the message.
Grenache and Swan Valley – yes, thanks. A lighter, brighter and fresher expression, this is a pretty wine with nice crunch in texture, plus notes of bright red fruits, amaro and a touch of sweetness, but still with great structure and fine tannin profile. Great drinking – easy drinking – is the message.
-
Dormilona Chenin Blanc
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
Energy is a sense here, as is huge drinkability.
A bit of a wild ride here, in the best sense, shows up with plenty of character, good refreshment factor, decent concentration and some pleasing vitality. Sea spray, green apples, white balsamic lift and some scattered green herbs find their way into this wine. Energy is a sense here, as is huge drinkability. A glassy texture that turns powdery is very pleasing too. An edgier expression, but done well.
-
Xanadu Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
Complex and seamless.
Does what it says on the label, and then some, making it a quintessential and elegant Margaret River cabernet. Mellow, even and flowing, there’s succulent fruit character, dark cherries, cola and coffee notes and touches of leafy herbs, but it’s all so well woven together. Complex, seamless. Yes.
-
Forest Hill Vineyard Mount Barker Riesling
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
An intense and engaging style that’s succulent and fine through the finish.
Very intense, limey, taut and refreshing, but you can see the X-factor that this wine brings to the table. With great persistence and tension, and precision on hand, this is an intense and engaging style that’s succulent and fine through the finish. Whoosh.
-
Fraser Gallop Estate Parterre Chardonnay
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
Beautifully drawn, and fine-boned.
A vivacious style, that’s tightly wound, mineral-driven and really charming, almost thirst-quenching, in nature with flinty elements, spice, just-ripe stone fruits and almond going on. There’s exceptional length, and it feels really precise and zesty at the same time. Beautifully drawn, and fine-boned.
-
Domaine Naturaliste Rachis Syrah
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
This wine delivers a message that reads with perfume, velvety texture, medium weight, spice, fine tannin and a general sense of energy.
How wonderful to see syrah at the apex of wines from Margaret River. This wine delivers a message that reads with perfume, velvety texture, medium weight, spice, fine tannin and a general sense of energy. There’s raspberry, cranberry, a touch of juniper botanical and herbal inflection, white pepper, a dash of clove and away we go. Quietly complex and very compelling.
-
Swinney Grenache
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
Structure, tension and a pleasing firmness, drawing out to a long, spicy finish.
A tremendous rendition of grenache, again showing us how excellent the variety can be from WA and the right sites. This wine is satiny, glossy and bright, yet serious, with a wonderful, fine-grained tannin profile and a distinct extension of flavour. The wine has structure, tension and a pleasing firmness, drawing out to a long, spicy finish. A serious wine.
-
Flying Fish Cove Wildberry Estate Reserve Chardonnay
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
An expression that flows beautifully, is supple and delivers a full flex of the variety with balance and finesse.
The golden colour of this wine reflects a deeper, more potent and powerful style, rich with nectarine and peach, green melon, cashew and cinnamon-clove spice. It’s an expression that flows beautifully, is supple and delivers a full flex of the variety with balance and finesse. Bold, and done very well.
-
Vasse Felix Premier Cabernet Sauvignon
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
A charismatic wine with a nice feel and even, persistent finish.
This wine has good flavour to go with supple texture, a saline element, some nuttiness with pleasing fino licks coupled with bruised apple, brown lime and ginger – in essence, there’s lots happening here. In all, it’s a charismatic wine with a nice feel and even, persistent finish. Classy is the byword.
-
Lowboi Gruner Veltliner
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
A pitch-perfect seaside-kinda white feel that should be seen more often in WA.
An excellent expression, showing the Austrians what for. It’s intense but refreshing, compact and concentrated, with ginger, tonic, kohlrabi and green apple galore. The bouquet and palate are in sync, the refreshment factor is high and there’s excellent length and minerally persistence. Sheesh, this is great drinking, and a pitch-perfect seaside-kinda white feel that should be seen more often in WA.
-
Cullen Wines Grace Madeline
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
A wine that shows up and goes the distance.
A wine that shows up and goes the distance, this is a serious expression – complex, layered, intense and savoury. Good get up and go with intensity of tropical fruits and a big squeeze of lime, yet nutty, saline elements and some toasty woody spices that chime in. A lot on, done superbly.
-
Castle Rock Estate Riesling
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
A rapier thrust of the variety that delivers strong fruit and mineral character in a very complex and energetic style.
A scintillating expression of riesling that’s juicy, fresh, bright, intense and driving with a huge swish of tangy acidity. It feels linear and pure – a rapier thrust of the variety that delivers strong fruit and mineral character in a very complex and energetic style. Drink with gusto.
-
Willow Bridge Estate G.S.M
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
Quite a bold expression, but it holds its balance well and delivers an attractive, smudged tannin finish for good measure.
A GSM with good structure and a sense of complexity with rich, ripe, dark cherry and red berry fruitiness, some sweet spice elements, choc-mint notes and a touch of leafy herbs in the mix. It’s quite a bold expression, but it holds its balance well and delivers an attractive, smudged tannin finish for good measure. Excellent drinking.
-
Oranje Tractor Elixyr Botanica Vermouth
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
Proper bitterness, great texture and spice.
With proper bitterness, great texture and spice, this tastes like an amaro and nails the brief well. There’s lots of slipperiness and judicious sweetness but it holds in all the botanicals and vermouth-like savoury and bitter elements with aplomb. Pure deliciousness. What a thing!
-
Stormflower Silver Lining
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
A vivacious, fruity style with creamy bubbles and good energy.
A vivacious, fruity style with creamy bubbles and good energy and lemon, lime, sea spray and cashew all going on. The energy is good here, with a texture that’s fresh feeling and generous, resulting in really pleasing drinking overall. Kudos.
-
Howard Park Swan Valley Grenache
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
A chillable red with carriage of flavour.
Pinosity and prettiness? It’s almost a nouveau style and brilliant for it. Offering up floral lift, rosewater and red cherry characters all built around a lovely, lithe and fresh styling. Attractive drinking. A chillable red with carriage of flavour. Yes, thanks.
-
Woodgate Bojangles Pinot Noir Brachetto Petillant Naturelle
VINTAGE
VARIETIES
REGION
Delightful, delicate, red-fruited and on the sweeter edge, this is stacked with easy appeal.
Delightful, delicate, red-fruited and on the sweeter edge, this is stacked with easy appeal: frisky bubbles, crisp texture, vibrant acidity. Not only does it nail the brief on a sweet(ish) style, there’s great energy and joy behind it all. Pleasing stuff, indeed.
THE
AWARDS
-
Battles Shiraz 2022
Wine of the Year
An outstanding wine from every angle, this satin-textured, perfumed, poised and utterly delicious red delivers all the detail of red berries, spice, savoury earthiness and layers of fine, puckering tannin. All this, delivered in a seamless flow that’s poised, vibrant, persistent and downright beautiful. That it’s gulpable, as well as something to pause and reflect on, is a distinct asset. What a wine.
-
Rhys Thomas, Swinney
Viticulturist of the Year
The Swinney vineyard in Frankland River has long been fertile ground for outstanding wines with a roll call of exceptional viticulturists as custodians. Rhys Thomas is the current caretaker and has done the seemingly impossible task of elevating quality, again, from these vines. Alongside inherent high standard of fruit, Thomas has continued the focus on sustainable practices with a commitment to organic farming and increasing soil and vineyard health. That Swinney as a standalone producer has released some of WA’s most striking wines of recent years from this site, is one testimony to Thomas’s oeuvre, though it’s the diverse array of winemakers and producers who share fruit from the vineyard, with brilliant and striking results, that lends further credence to the formidable work that finds Thomas the recipient of this award.
-
Vino Volta
Best Emerging Producer
Vino Volta, the standalone project of Garth Cliff and Kristen McGann, is a tearaway wine offering that has further enhanced the reputation of the homebase growing region of Swan Valley while delivering some of WA’s most exciting ‘new wines’. While Cliff and McGann have extensive wine experience prior to Vino Volta’s arrival, their VV wines seem to marry a beautiful balance between more expressive, avant garde production and science-based know-how, with a diverse array of wine styles produced each year. From pet nats to skin-fermented white wines through to elegant, finer-boned grenache, Vino Volta has wowed for its quality basis and distinct flair for wines of broad appeal – beyond this, Cliff seems to have an ingrained knowledge of distinguished vineyard sites and the bigger-picture potential available to the wonderful Swan Valley region. Kudos is due for Vino Volta’s brilliant wines.
-
Frankland Estate
Producer of the Year
While there was a breadth of contenders for this inaugural award, the judges were drawn to the outstanding wines, farming, longevity and general excellence under the charter of Frankland Estate. Renowned not only for the pioneering approach to Great Southern, but upper echelon wines, excellence in (organic certified) viticulture, benchmark wines from the region (and WA generally), while applying progressive mores to new-release wine styles, with a commitment to the overall betterment of Western Australia’s wine scene through participation and community-minded activity. Outstanding in all facets, Frankland Estate is at the vanguard of WA wine.
-
Clive Otto, Fraser Gallop Estate
Winemaker of the Year
Tanzania-born Clive Otto spent his formative WA winemaking years at the vaunted Vasse Felix before joining Fraser Gallop in 2006/2007. High-quality wines, exceptional regional staples and a nous for consistency in winemaking have all underpinned his distinguished career. It was hard to ignore the talent and reach of Otto with high-calibre results for Fraser Gallop wines following the judging of this year’s WA Good Food Guide Wine Awards. This award also looks to Otto’s legacy work, with Fraser Gallop’s ascension into fine-wine territory coupled with Otto’s arrival at the winery, with judges agreeing that Otto’s deep experience and flair for elevating Margaret River staple varieties was important as an overall credential for this award. The judges deemed Otto the best candidate for this inaugural award and congratulate him on his significant impact on Western Australia wines.
-
McHenry Hohnen Hazel’s Vineyard Chardonnay 2022
Best Single Vineyard Wine
This award celebrates the best of single-vineyard wines from Western Australia, with the focus on the WA Good Food Guide Wine Awards Top 25 Wines and the corresponding highest-ranked single-vineyard wine produced by a grower-producer. McHenry Hohnen takes out this honour with the stellar Hazel’s chardonnay from the distinguished Hazel’s Vineyard. The site is McHenry Hohnen’s most southerly vineyard, located not far from the bucolic town of Witchcliffe in Margaret River. The vineyard is certified biodynamic and set on free-draining, ironstone gravel loam soils. The resulting chardonnay is striking for its persistence, sense of minerality, textural nuance and general deliciousness.
-
Oranje Tractor Wine Elixyr Botanica Vinum Absinthium Vermouth
Experimental Wine of the Year
The WA Good Food Guide Wine Awards values innovation and creativity in winemaking and actively seeks out top examples of distinct and diverse wines that are tasted through the wine judging period. The Oranje Tractor Elixir Botanica Vermouth is a striking, complex vermouth that marries a base of merlot wine with an array of estate-grown (and certified organic) herbs, spices, honey, florals and botanicals and nuts. Additionally, locally produced spirit fortifies the vermouth. It’s an outstanding drink, pleasing in its balance of bitterness and inherent fruitiness of merlot with a complexity derived from its varied botanical elements. Overall, it offers a general sense of high drinkability. Drink this over ice with a wedge of blood orange, legs dangling in swimming pool.
-
McHenry Hohnen Hazel’s Vineyard Chardonnay 2022
Best Certified Organic or Biodynamic Wine
The WA Good Food Guide Wine Awards encourages the pursuit of better-practice farming in viticulture and has focused on the merits of organic and biodynamic certification as a lens for a top wine award each year. The highest ranked certified organic or certified biodynamic wine judged in the Top 25 best wines is the McHenry Hohnen 2022 Hazel’s Chardonnay. It’s a wine of immense pleasure, expressive in its reflection of the variety, and generally impressed judges for its vitality, ease of consumption and quiet complexity. It’s a wine that stands out from the crowd and is evidently grown and made from vines that have been cared for with detail.
-
Battles Shiraz 2022, Frankland River
Regional Award Winner: Best Great Southern Wine
Delivering strong DNA of Frankland River shiraz, this svelte and finely wrought shiraz is pitched perfectly at medium weight with silkiness of texture, fine, silty tannin, lavish perfume and red berry fruits at its essence. There’s plenty of the ephemeral sense of ‘complexity’ on hand and a sense that balance and length of flavour are likewise impressive. Overall, a succulent, fragrant, spicy red of top-flight calibre.
-
McHenry Hohnen Hazel’s Vineyard Chardonnay 2022, Margaret River
Regional Award Winner: Best Margaret River Wine
A wonderful interpretation of Margaret River’s famed white grape asset, this is a distinct chardonnay for its strong mineral character and savoury nuttiness woven through more classic green apple, stone fruit and citrus characters. A textural white of high deliciousness that shines a somewhat alternative light, positively so, on the regional hero white variety.
-
Vino Volta Post Modern Seriousism Grenache 2022, Swan Valley
Regional Award Winner: Best Swan Valley Wine
Swan Valley has had new life breathed into it through the eyes of younger generation and avant garde producers – Vino Volta counted among them. This is a beautifully pitched, finer-boned expression of the regional hero-red variety, grenache, that’s vividly perfumed, floral, with notes of sweet spice and cherry juice, with similar flavours set in a lighter weight frame.
-
Willow Bridge Estate G.S.M 2022, Geographe
Regional Award Winner: Best Geographe Wine
While Geographe does well with lesser-sung varieties, this wine was compelling for its potency and its grace. It has a sweet spice-laced perfume and flavours with deep concentration of darker berry and plummy fruit. Hearty, with lusty tannin, it’s a ripper red of vivacious character.
-
Woodgate Bojangles Pinot Noir Brachetto Petillant Naturelle NV, Manjimup
Regional Award Winner: Best Southern Forests Wine
Southern Forests, particularly Manjimup here, delivers an array of wine styles with regional distinction, with this sweet, naturally sparkling wine perhaps a bit out of the box. That being said, it prosecutes its case well, with sweetness balanced by crunchy acidity, frisky, persistent bubbles, and overall a stellar drinkability that thrilled judges.
-
Myattsfield Vineyards Vermentino 2023, Perth Hills
Regional Award Winner: Best Perth Hills Wine
Perth Hills delivers a breadth of wines and wine styles with the white variety vermentino a newer potential thanks to this wine. It delivers that sense of seaside white wine with aplomb: it’s crisp in texture, with gentle saline minerality as an undercurrent, and citrus and green apple meshed to light herbal notes as a mainstay. A thirst-quenching and revitalising, light and fresh white of great charisma.
Lead photo: Jessica Wyld